Lawyer alleges town violated NY law, synagogue's religious freedom in suit over torn Israeli flag

The Town of Ramapo, New York has been stuck with a tricky political issue since an ultra-Orthodox Jewish group tore down an Israeli flag that was illegally placed on the side of the town's municipal building. The group, led by an elderly rabbi who represented himself in court, successfully argued that the display violated his religious beliefs and that tearing it down was a legitimate exercise of free expression. The group was released without charge but the controversy didn't end there...

Now, the rabbi and another community member have filed a lawsuit against the town for violating their religious freedom and New York law. The lawsuit argues that the town violated the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000 and the US and New York Constitutions by flying the flag on town property.

The plaintiffs argue that the Satmar Jewish community, which comprises a significant portion of the town's population and has deep roots in the area, opposes Israel as a political entity and that displaying the flag on town property violates their religious principles. Furthermore, the lawsuit alleges that the town's decision to fly the flag violated the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000 because it significantly burdened the Satmar community's religious practice and beliefs without a compelling interest. In addition, the lawsuit alleges that the town's decision to fly the flag violated the US and New York Constitutions because it endorsed religion and violated the Establishment Clause.

The lawsuit asks the court to issue an order directing the town to remove the flag and to cease and desist from displaying it or any other foreign flag on town property.

The lawyer representing the plaintiffs, Stanley L. Cohen, is no stranger to religious freedom cases. He has argued numerous cases before the United States Supreme Court and has successfully challenged religious exemptions on behalf of his clients. He is confident that this case will be no different and that the court will rule in his client's favor.

Only time will tell if the town of Ramapo will be forced to remove the Israeli flag from its municipal building. But one thing is for sure: this case is just another example of the complex interplay between religion, politics, and law in modern society.

Read more